Congress must demand answers on Bergdahl prison swap
By Rob Portman
June 12, 2014
The administration’s decision to release five top Taliban leaders in exchange for Sergeant Bowe Bergdahl without consulting Congress violated the clear language of two laws and has put American lives in more danger.
This is not an issue of partisan politics. Congressional leaders on both sides of the aisle have expressed concern about how this exchange was handled. Nor is it about what kind of soldier Sergeant Bergdahl may have been. I trust the Army will handle that matter appropriately. This is about an administration that ignored a direct requirement to consult with Congress and provide a detailed explanation before releasing dangerous detainees back into the field, where they will likely resume combat against our men and women in uniform and our allies in Afghanistan.
And that’s not just my opinion—it is the administration’s own assessment.
In a hearing before the Senate Armed Services Committee in 2012, the president’s Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, reiterated a 2010 administration assessment that these five Taliban leaders posed a high risk of returning to the fight. On this point, Director Clapper did not equivocate, saying, “I do not think anyone harbors any illusions about these five Taliban members and what they might do if they were transferred.”
These men were senior members of the Taliban. They include the Taliban Deputy Defense Minister, Deputy Minister of Intelligence, and Minister of the Interior. Some were closely associated with Usama bin Laden or Al Qaeda. Two are wanted by the United Nations for war crimes.
Yet despite these red flags—which, according to reports in the press, were reiterated during internal White House debates over the transfer—President Obama released these men anyway. And he did so in violation of a clear requirement that he consult with Congress before releasing detainees housed at Guantanamo.
This requirement was put in place precisely to avoid the situation we now face. It requires the President to explain the basis for a release, why it is in the country’s national security interest, and what actions the Administration will take to ensure that released detainees do not return to threaten American lives.
Had the president followed this requirement—one that he signed into law as part of the 2014 National Defense Authorization Act and the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2014—then many of the dangers posed by this decision could have been avoided altogether.
The Taliban have reacted to the release of their top commanders with celebration. Taliban supreme leader Mullah Mohammad Omar—who currently has a $10 Million reward on his head for his role in the September 11 terrorist attacks—called the transfer “a great victory” in the ongoing Afghan war.
Because make no mistake—the war is ongoing. Already this month, eight American servicemen have lost their lives in Afghanistan. One can hardly doubt that the administration’s decision to release these Taliban leaders will put more American lives at risk.
We must not be blind to the fact that the Taliban aims to regain as much power as they can in Afghanistan and Pakistan. That means a return to oppression, human rights abuses, the suppression of women’s rights, and most importantly, the complicit harboring of their ally, Al Qaeda. We have just returned to them their leadership team to help achieve that aim.
Read More: http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2014/06/12/congress-must-demand-answers-on-bergdahl-prison-swap/